Even if this is true. The current earth is just "re-newed" as opposed to altogether new, and heaven is "re-newed" as opposed to altogether new from scratch.
Either way... it hasn't happened yet. That is my point.
The New Jerusalem is in heaven now, the third heaven, where God is, where Jesus is, who is sat at God's right hand.
The New Jerusalem is the spiritual Jerusalem, it is being built up as we speak, it is the Church, the ekklesia. The New Jerusalem is not complete yet because all the Names in the book of Life and the Lamb are not in it, it is being built up and Christ is the Head.
As you say brother, it doesn't matter to us whether the earth is new or new as existing earth renewed, which ever happens according to God's will, will be Paradise, no sin on earth, no curse on the earth, everything will be restored, made new.
As far as the New Jerusalem... I believe you are right. Now while heaven may or may not be a physical place. The New Jerusalem is definitely a physical place with physical dimensions
made of physical elements.
The New Jerusalem in heaven now I believe is spiritual, some say it is physical because when it comes to earth it is physical, it depends on how we view heaven, is heaven spiritual or physical, I understand it as being spiritual, therefore the New Jerusalem which is not complete and is in heaven must also be spiritual. We welcome all comments of course and are open minded to the translation and understanding of the scriptures.
Now when John was called up into heaven he saw the New Jerusalem, not as it is now, being built up,
but in it's completed form. What a sight brother.
Revelation 1:1-2 (NKJV)
The Revelation of Jesus Christ, which God gave Him to show His servants--things which must shortly take place. And He sent and signified
it by His angel to His servant John, who bore witness to the word of God, and to the testimony of Jesus Christ,
to all things that he saw.
John saw the finished New Jerusalem, and he saw it come down onto the new earth. The New Jerusalem is the Church, the ekklesia, the spirit and souls of all who are saved. In the OT was the Tabernacle and the Temple, but in the NT time of the Gentiles it is the Church of Jesus Christ, made up from those spiritual stones on earth who have followed Christ as Lord and Head of His Church.
In heaven now it is spiritual, when it comes down to earth it will be physical, I believe, how can this be? Nothing is impossible for God, and after all did he not create our planet, did he not create the universe from nothing, he sure did. PTL.
The New Jerusalem, the Tabernacle of God, the Holy City is heaven on earth, God with man, Emmanuel.
John saw the final stages of God coming back down to earth to be with his people, Christ is on the throne, he has created a place for us. I believe God's mansion we read where he has created a place for us (saved souls) is in the New Jerusalem. Sadly this scripture is used for so many funerals and crematorium services, wrong teachings spoken to the grieving souls, making them believe the person who has passed away, who is not saved, has gone to heaven (no one goes to heaven, only the spirit and soul of a true believer). The world believes the lie. Sad, very sad. I have a Christian brother not far from here, I remember him telling me last year, he went to the funeral service of a close family member, after the service he approached the minister and expressed his concern for telling lies, scriptural untruths to those still living. The minister became annoyed and after words like, how dare you talk to me like that my brother in Christ came away, brushing the sand off his feet, but the lies had been told. Sad, very sad.
But if I understand you correctly here (and it's possible I am mistaken)... you believe the dead saints are currently floating around in heaven as bodiless apparitions?
That either will be re-joined with their old bodys or else get new bodys at the resurrection. You believe that when Jesus says "the dead will rise", it simply means the bodies.
The Bible does say even the wicked are resurrected in a couple of places. Where are their souls/spirits now?
What I am saying is that the saved spirit and soul goes to be with the Lord, as I understand it, floating around I do not know, I have not read scripture confirming this. But I do believe that is the case, we are spirits, spiritual stones in the ekklesia, the spiritual body of Christ. But one day, the last day, we will receive our new glorious bodies and be with the Lord 'on earth' for ever.
We do not go to heaven, only the spirit and soul of believers for a period of time. We do not go to heaven, God made earth for us, he will restore, make new earth for us, then God, through Jesus will return to earth to be with us forever. Emmanuel God with us. (Not us with God, we are with him but He comes to us)
Hope I am making sense brother, I welcome the understanding of other brothers and sisters, including your dear self my friend.
There are troubling times ahead but, it will all be worth it for every saved soul, what a place the new earth will be, what a building the New Jerusalem will be, we will be in awe my friend.
PTL \o/