• Welcome to Talk Jesus Christian Forums

    Celebrating 20 Years!

    A bible based, Jesus Christ centered community.

    Register Log In

Anihilationism

Active
Plenty of scriptural passages indicate those that reject God suffer eternally. Annihilation is not justice for the wicked, and God is a God of perfect justice. As God has said: "they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.” Matthew 25:46.

Blessings
 
Active
I'm sure. The word aion doesn't mean eternal. It's a poor translation. Also, the soul isn't eternal. God said the soul that sins shall die. Isaiah said that Jesus poured out His soul unto death. Jesus also spoke if Gid destroying both body and soul in Gehenna.
Brother, the greek word aiōnion is used 45 times and each time is translated either as eternal, forever, everlasting, both for life and death. The body may perish, but the soul is eternal.

Blessings
 
Active
Plenty of scriptural passages indicate those that reject God suffer eternally. Annihilation is not justice for the wicked, and God is a God of perfect justice. As God has said: "they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.” Matthew 25:46.

Blessings
I think we've determined from Scripture pretty solidly that aion doesn't mean eternal, thus people don't suffer enterally. It is interesting that you mention justice. Justice means equity. Equity is an eye for an eye, but didn't God say that? What isn't justice is telling someone that if they sin they will die, and then after they sin to tell them that instead of the stated punishment they are going to burn for eternity. That's actually called the, "The Bait and Switch". It's deceptive. God said through Ezekiel, 'the soul that sins shall die'. Paul said, 'the wages of sin is death'. These are both statements that tell us what the result of sin is.

If we take the word aion out of the picture, can one really make an argument for eternal torment? If not, isn't it dangerous to form a doctrine on the definition of a single word, especially when it can be shown that that definition is highly questionable?
 
Active
I think we've determined from Scripture pretty solidly that aion doesn't mean eternal, thus people don't suffer enterally. It is interesting that you mention justice. Justice means equity. Equity is an eye for an eye, but didn't God say that? What isn't justice is telling someone that if they sin they will die, and then after they sin to tell them that instead of the stated punishment they are going to burn for eternity. That's actually called the, "The Bait and Switch". It's deceptive. God said through Ezekiel, 'the soul that sins shall die'. Paul said, 'the wages of sin is death'. These are both statements that tell us what the result of sin is.

If we take the word aion out of the picture, can one really make an argument for eternal torment? If not, isn't it dangerous to form a doctrine on the definition of a single word, especially when it can be shown that that definition is highly questionable?
No, you have not proven aiōnion does not literally mean eternal, because it literally means eternal. And NO you can't take the word aiōnio out of scripture: it's written into the text as with an iron pen. Deal with it, because aiōnionas is as theopneustos as the passage of John 3:16.

Blessings
 
Active
Brother, the greek word aiōnion is used 45 times and each time is translated either as eternal, forever, everlasting, both for life and death. The body may perish, but the soul is eternal.

Blessings
Hi Jerry,

Yes, it is translated eternal. it doesn't matter how many times it's used. If they are wrong the first time, the rest will be also. Jesus spoke of the end of the aion, and of the aion to come. If aion is eternal, how can it end? How can there be another one? We need to look at how definitions are determined. Firstly, everyone who translates already has a belief system in place. Sometimes that belief system influences how they translate. This is the case with the word aion. People see it used in reference to life and say it means eternal. However, when Jesus says it ends they translate it as world or age. Why would they do that? Because it doesn't fit what they believe. They wouldn't translate it in a way they believed was wrong. They're going to translated it as they believe is correct. Of course they also believe that what they believe is correct. This is why we need to look at how these words are used in Scripture. We need to determine if the translators are correct.
 
Active
No, you have not proven aiōnion does not literally mean eternal, because it literally means eternal. And NO you can't take the word aiōnio out of scripture: it's written into the text as with an iron pen. Deal with it, because aiōnionas is as theopneustos as the passage of John 3:16.

Blessings
If you read through the thread I believe you'll see that I have. No one said to take the word aion out of Scripture. I said take it out of the argument for eternal. Can you make a case for eternal punishment without the word aion. If not then the idea is based on a single definition, which can be shown to be wrong.
 
Active
Hi Jerry,

Yes, it is translated eternal. it doesn't matter how many times it's used. If they are wrong the first time, the rest will be also. Jesus spoke of the end of the aion, and of the aion to come. If aion is eternal, how can it end? How can there be another one? We need to look at how definitions are determined. Firstly, everyone who translates already has a belief system in place. Sometimes that belief system influences how they translate. This is the case with the word aion. People see it used in reference to life and say it means eternal. However, when Jesus says it ends they translate it as world or age. Why would they do that? Because it doesn't fit what they believe. They wouldn't translate it in a way they believed was wrong. They're going to translated it as they believe is correct. Of course they also believe that what they believe is correct. This is why we need to look at how these words are used in Scripture. We need to determine if the translators are correct.
Definition of aion: for ever, an unbroken age, perpetuity of time, eternity, the worlds, universe, period of time, age

Definition of aiōnion: indeterminate as to duration, eternal, everlasting,

God is not the author of confusion. If aiōnion is used by the Holy Spirit to describe eternal life, and the same word used by the Holy Spirit to describe etetnal punishment, I'll go with God's comprehensive clarity.

Blessings
 
Active
Definition of aion: for ever, an unbroken age, perpetuity of time, eternity, the worlds, universe, period of time, age

Definition of aiōnion: indeterminate as to duration, eternal, everlasting,

God is not the author of confusion. If aiōnion is used by the Holy Spirit to describe eternal life, and the same word used by the Holy Spirit to describe etetnal punishment, I'll go with God's comprehensive clarity.

Blessings

But God had them use the word aion, not eternal. It is translators who chose the word eternal. This is the flaw in the argument. Again, Jesus spoke of the end of the aion. How is something that ends eternal?

39 The enemy that sowed them is the devil; the harvest is the end of the world; and the reapers are the angels. (Matt. 13:39 KJV)

49 So shall it be at the end of the world: the angels shall come forth, and sever the wicked from among the just, (Matt. 13:49 KJV)

20 Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: and, lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world. Amen. (Matt. 28:20 KJV)

The apostles too spoke of the end of the aion.

3 And as he sat upon the mount of Olives, the disciples came unto him privately, saying, Tell us, when shall these things be? and what shall be the sign of thy coming, and of the end of the world? (Matt. 24:3 KJV)

You said you'll go with God's comprehensive clarity. Here you go, you have it from the mouth of Jesus.
 
Active
But God had them use the word aion, not eternal. It is translators who chose the word eternal. This is the flaw in the argument. Again, Jesus spoke of the end of the aion. How is something that ends eternal?

39 The enemy that sowed them is the devil; the harvest is the end of the world; and the reapers are the angels. (Matt. 13:39 KJV)

49 So shall it be at the end of the world: the angels shall come forth, and sever the wicked from among the just, (Matt. 13:49 KJV)

20 Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: and, lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world. Amen. (Matt. 28:20 KJV)

The apostles too spoke of the end of the aion.

3 And as he sat upon the mount of Olives, the disciples came unto him privately, saying, Tell us, when shall these things be? and what shall be the sign of thy coming, and of the end of the world? (Matt. 24:3 KJV)

You said you'll go with God's comprehensive clarity. Here you go, you have it from the mouth of Jesus.
Brother, no need to go any further. You aren't convincing at all.

Jesus said: My sheep listen to My voice; I know them, and they follow Me. I give them eternal (aiōnion) life and they will never perish. No one can snatch them out of My hand. John 10:27-28.

And Jesus said of the wicked: "And these will go away into eternal (aiōnion) punishment, but the righteous into eternal (aiōnion) life.”

Like I said brother, my God is not the author of confusion and is comprehensively clear. Eternal life is eternal. Eternal punishment is eternal.

Blessings
 
Active
Brother, no need to go any further. You aren't convincing at all.

Jesus said: My sheep listen to My voice; I know them, and they follow Me. I give them eternal (aiōnion) life and they will never perish. No one can snatch them out of My hand. John 10:27-28.

And Jesus said of the wicked: "And these will go away into eternal (aiōnion) punishment, but the righteous into eternal (aiōnion) life.”

Like I said brother, my God is not the author of confusion and is comprehensively clear. Eternal life is eternal. Eternal punishment is eternal.

Blessings

Jesus said aion, not eternal. Why haven't you addressed the evidence I've presented? If you're not interested in discussing it why did you comment on my post?
 
Active
Jesus said aion, not eternal. Why haven't you addressed the evidence I've presented? If you're not interested in discussing it why did you comment on my post?

I gave you sufficient evidence of the Greek and how it is used in the text. If you choose to ignore it, or stubbornly stick with your flawed reading, so be it. By the way, are you SDA?

Blessings.
 
Active
I gave you sufficient evidence of the Greek and how it is used in the text. If you choose to ignore it, or stubbornly stick with your flawed reading, so be it. By the way, are you SDA?

Blessings.
Where? You said it was used of aionios life and punishment. You didn't show how the Greek was used. Again, please address the evidence. I've not ignored anything you've said. I addressed your use of aion. I also pointed out that Jesus didn't use the word eternal. That is from the translators.
 
Active
@Butch5

Greetings,

thank you for your patience.
A lot of water has gone under the bridge
but
the bridge still stands!

I suppose one question is, is there an endless age? In pondering this, can we and do we consider the Lord Who is without beginning and end?


May i also pick up on the thought of the notion that "if i am simply going to cease to exist when i die, what does it matter?"


Bless you ....><>

I don't think it will matter. If it did God would not of said you will die . What does matter is have we been given a new spirit that will never die. . salavation ?
 
Active
Where? You said it was used of aionios life and punishment. You didn't show how the Greek was used. Again, please address the evidence. I've not ignored anything you've said. I addressed your use of aion. I also pointed out that Jesus didn't use the word eternal. That is from the translators.
Aiōnion is the Greek word for eternal, the manuscripts agree, and the translators agreed that when the manuscripts quote Jesus regarding eternal life and eternal punishment, HE used the word aiōnion, or its Hebrew or Aramaic equivalent, which means eternal. If it was not by acclamation, then by super majority consensus those learned translators of the Greek and Hebrew agreed that what Jesus was quoted to have said and meant is eternal, as in eternal.

Blessings
 
Active
Aiōnion is the Greek word for eternal, the manuscripts agree, and the translators agreed that when the manuscripts quote Jesus regarding eternal life and eternal punishment, HE used the word aiōnion, or its Hebrew or Aramaic equivalent, which means eternal. If it was not by acclamation, then by super majority consensus those learned translators of the Greek and Hebrew agreed that what Jesus was quoted to have said and meant is eternal, as in eternal.

Blessings


Whoever has the Son has eternal life. Those who do not have the Spirit of Christ will never rise again forever and ever. Thier temporal body and temoporal spirit returns to the father .Jesus said marvel not a person must be born again.

Hell is the wage of sin the suffering of these corrupted bodies of death . The first death .
 
Active
Whoever has the Son has eternal life. Those who do not have the Spirit of Christ will never rise again forever and ever. Thier temporal body and temoporal spirit returns to the father .Jesus said marvel not a person must be born again.

Hell is the wage of sin the suffering of these corrupted bodies of death . The first death .
That does not line up with the Word at all....That's an intellectual interpretation of the Word...As the Holy Spirit what is what...
 
Active
Whoever has the Son has eternal life. Those who do not have the Spirit of Christ will never rise again forever and ever. Thier temporal body and temoporal spirit returns to the father .Jesus said marvel not a person must be born again.

Hell is the wage of sin the suffering of these corrupted bodies of death . The first death .
Brother,

The wages of sin is death. All men sin therefore all die. Hell is for the unrepentant sinner. We live eternally in heaven because we are repentant and regenerated. We have a living savior - Jesus Christ.

Blessings
 
Active
Whoever has the Son has eternal life. Those who do not have the Spirit of Christ will never rise again forever and ever. Thier temporal body and temoporal spirit returns to the father .Jesus said marvel not a person must be born again.

Hell is the wage of sin the suffering of these corrupted bodies of death . The first death .
What about the verses that say the flesh body will return to dust? The first death...The second death is where the spirit/soul is forever separated from Life...who is God.... Stick with what the Word says and forget trying to translate it into what you want it to say.
 
Active
I think as Christians we would make progress if we stopped using the English word hell and just used the Biblical words of, Hades, Gehenna, and Tartarus. Using the word hell causes much confusion because these Greek words are conflated using the word hell
 
Top