Brother in Christ, James1523: Denominations per se are not the Body of Christ, but the people who are born again believers are in the Body of Christ. I will not speak for all denominations, only the three I was involved in; Conservative Baptist, American Baptist Churches of the USA, and Southern Baptist. All of these denominations clearly state they, as believers olone, are a part of the Body of Christ, not the man orginazation, but as each believer has becomes a genuine born again believer, Never have I heard anything about "oneness", and a certian denomination being selective and beibg the BODY. Denominations for example Southern Baptist, is the name a group of Christians who each church help support Missions, because a large group of believers can send out missions fully equiped so they can minister without writting hundreds of letters asking for money. The best use of a mission is to have needs met before they leave the US. Of couurse denominations will not be in heaven, where did you assume they would? Denominations are the name given over the actual name if the group og beleivers working together.
Denominations will state that..they are part of the Body of Christ.. but they do not practice the Body of Christ...they remain in independence...why they do not share bread and wine together every Sunday??
Why some meet in their Baptist church and have bread and wine but others meet in pentecostal church on the same street close by and do not all meet together? If you have children do you not ask them all to sit at the dinner table together to share the meal? Or do you separate them into different rooms of your house according to what they believe???
The key feature of the Body of Christ is unity and oneness... here Paul speaks to
all the believers in the city of Corinth (not all the believers within a sect/party/denomination):
1 Cor 12:21 "The eye cannot say to the hand, "I don't need you!" And the head cannot say to the feet, "I don't need you!""
When American Baptist or Lutheran or any group of believers.. say they can do God's work by themselves.. they are doing like says in 1 Cor 12:21 "I don't need you".
Also, taking a name other than Christ...of doctrinal belief or practice (e.g. baptist) or nationality (e.g. American) is no where supported in scripture. In Heaven if God is not going to separate believers by their belief or nationality or race.. then why should we the church.. as God's dwelling place on Earth.. separate?
Dear friend look closely at Matthew 25:34-46. Jesus did for certian tell us we are to feed the hungry, give a drink for the thursty, to clothe in need of clothing, heal the sick, visit those in prison, the list goes far beyond what is mentioned above. Jesus said to the extent that we do this even to the least of them to our brothers and sister's of His, wehavedone these kindnesses to HIM. my simple version. The New Testament is full of examples that we are to follow. Good works do not save anyone. Good works are a result of being a genuine Christian. Jesus did all the things required of a Jew, He lived and died and was killed by the very istitution that had become a religion not their faith in God. Jesus came for the Jews first even the disciples said thid until Paul was sent by God to the Gentiles.
You speak of many good works and they are necessary of course but you have missed the key thing.. unity and oneness. Based on Jesus's prayer in John 17.. Unity and oneness is a greater testimony to the world than many good works. Consider Jesus's prayer:
John 17:20 ""My prayer is not for them alone.
I pray also for those who will believe in me through their message,"
This prayer is not just for the early church, but for all of us who have believe today.
John 17:21
"
that all of them may be one, Father, just as you are in me and I am in you. May they also be in us so that the world may believe that you have sent me."
John 17:23
"I am in them and you are in me.
May they experience such perfect unity that the world will know that you sent me and that you love them as much as you love me."
Denominations and divisions are not "perfect unity".
Consider the early church.. the apostles and other ministers had different ministeries.. but they all ministered to the one body of Christ. They did not separate themselves and call themselve by name of who they followed:
1 Cor 3:4 "For when one says, "I follow Paul," and another, "I follow Apollos," are you not mere men?"
When we say I follow Baptist.. I follow Luther (eg Lutheran), I follow Calvin (eg Presbyterian).. are we not mere men?
"Anyone who supports denominations does not know God very well...Paul said in 1 Corinthians 3:1 ("And I, brenthren, could not speak to you as to spiriitual men, but as to men of flesh, as to infants in Christ." those who follow deniminations are not spiritual but worldy, mere men babes in Christ. When we see God in a fuller way, we cannot agree with divisions and longer. You have made some reall judgemental statements, it is remarkable you have such spirituality to be able to adjudicate those who support a denomination who seeks only to equip people to know who Jesus is.
I speak of following the denomination... following, supporting, promoting, the denomination, to the exclusion of all others, making separation, division and distinction between fellow believers in the Lord. This is not a judgement but a statement of fact according to 1 Cor 3:1 "worldly, men of flesh, infants in Christ".. an infant in Christ does not know Christ well enough to overcome differences/disagreements in non-essential doctrine and unite as one church in the Lord.
"Denominations do many good things but so do Muslim groups and athesists and Buddhist organizations also do good things in tough times." Tell me where and when you have ever heard that Muslims have done good things? I have never heard of a Buddhist organization helping anything or anyone. Only as a a person in involved in the mosques or temples is any good deed done.
There are many... organisations such as "Islamic Relief"..buddhist organisations such as "Tzu Chi foundation"..charity organisations, both religious and non-religious are numerous.
"A main reason why denominations exist today is for convenience. It is convenient to meet with like-minded brethern.. it si easier..but it is not God's will." You have just spoken for God, are you aware of that? Scripture (the Bible) is complete now, so please give a verse to support your statement! Unless you can provide a verse to support you statement you are a false teacher!
OK some verses to support my statement:
All churches in the bible were by
city name not denominational name..
if you can find evidence of even one denomination in the Bible then please provide the verse!
Rev 3:3 To the angelof the church in Sardis write:
etc
Even so, this is not a name of idenitfication.. they all identified themselves as simply Christians:
Acts 11:26 "And when he had found him, he brought him unto Antioch. And it came to pass, that a whole year they assembled themselves with the church, and taught much people. And the disciples were called Christians first in Antioch."
Antioch is a city, not denomination. There was only one church in Antioch, and all the believers within that city were in the church in Antioch. They did not call themselves "the Antioch Christians", or any other name.. they just called themselves Christians. There were both Jew and Gentile Christians.. but they did not divide themself and say "I am Jew Christian or I am Gentile Christian"...Jew and Gentile did not meet separately but together:
Even so-called "messianic/Jewish " denominations are also guilty of dividing the Body of Christ..because Jew and Gentile met and ate together in the bible... Gal 2:12 "When he first arrived, he ate with the Gentile Christians, who were not circumcised. But afterward, when some friends of James came, Peter wouldn't eat with the Gentiles anymore. He was afraid of criticism from these people who insisted on the necessity of circumcision."
Let me make clear that Christians in the Bible were
never identified by where they met (park, home, city, country, nation), what they believed (baptism, tongue speaking, Saturday Sabbath keeping), or their race or culture (American, Chinese, Korean )..but only by who they believed in (Christ Jesus) and the city or village in which they lived (church in Jerusalem, church in Ephesus.. etc).
Further proof is that the Bible reveals that unity and oneness is God's heart:
1 Cor 1:13 "Is Christ divided? Was Paul crucified for you? Were you baptized into the name of Paul?"
If Christ is divided then we should meet together in divisions. But if Christ is not divided then we should not.
1 Cor 12:21 The eye cannot say to the hand, “I have no need of you,” nor again the head to the feet, “I have no need of you.”
Meeting in denominations separates ourselves from other believers hence "I have no need of you". This is seen clearly when there are two or more denominations on the same street. Two or more denomination on same street - there is no practical reason they cannot meet together.. there is no reason they cannot meet together to share bread and wine.. pray, sing to God and worship. Instead of sharing one loaf they all share many loaves but the bible says:
1 Cor 10:17 "Because there is one loaf, we, who are many, are one body, for we all share the one loaf."
"We should not make any distinction and not make a dividing wall between us. God receives them but we don't because we love the denomination more than God. If we love God more than the denomination there is no reason to separate our self from other believers. Friend by what you are saying I feel no Christian love for me, because I go to a Baptist Church that supports huge needs by a large number of churches that cam do much more than a single church. I have been a member of a Bible Church non-denominational church that sent a few hundred dollars a year to a few missions. I never heard then malign or critccize any denomination, I saw love and respect for genuine beleievers in Christ Jesus. Why do you feel the right to condemn and backbight all denominations as if all fenominations are the same? The truth is denominations are not the samne.
Genuine love for fellow believers in Christ is shown by meeting together with them in oneness: See John 17:22-23 :
John 17:22-23 "I have given them the glory that you gave me, that they may be one as we are one— I in them and you in me—so that they may be brought to complete unity. Then the world will know that you sent me and have loved them even as you have loved me."
Separation into denominations because of non-essential doctrinal difference is not a sign of love and respect for
all believers in Christ.
The Body of Christ being divided into denominations is not God's will (see Jesus's prayer in John 17 and other verses I give above).. therefore all denominations are the same in this respect...not in the will of God..
Jesus never started them.. the apostles never started them..there will not be denomination in Heaven... so if you have bible verses to prove that denominations are God's will then please post them.
"But in God's church everyone is on the same level, no one is better than another..there are no pastors better than laity... 'common people' ..pastors don't lead from the front abd top down, they lead by example. Many pastors are like mini-popes in charge of their church. But there is only one shepherd in the church..Jesus Christ" ..........".... bible says only one church in each city." Once again you speak for God and give no Scripture to back your statement! I know of no Scripture that says only one church in each city. How would Los Angels work that out, or Denver, New york?
In the Bible from the book of Acts and Paul's epistles and the book of Revelation we see that there was the church (singular) in Jerusalem, Antioch, Corinth, Ephesus, Rome, Corinth, Phillipi.. these are city names not denominational names. The apostles commissioned by the Lord Jesus only established one church in each city...not many churches within each city, and definitely not identified by their belief, practice, leader (there was no "church of Paul, or church of Peter".. There are no denominational names in the bible...but if you know of any then please provide the verse.
Jesus mentioned the word "LOVE" 54 times in the four Gospels all are related to His love for His father or how we are to love. You have not even said the word "love". How can we as genuine disciples of Jesus Christ show the world we are followers of Jesus if there bitter attacks made toward those who are christians, but have some areas of disagreement? How can a person be a christian and speak misconceptions about a group of felloe believers wfo seek to minister ib a large group rather than a small or large single church.
The word love is not in the book of Acts even once. Even though the book of Acts is the book recording the spreading of the gospel and building up of church.. even though the book of Acts spans 30 years and is a long book with 28 chapters.. and it records the preaching of the gospel to all kinds of people...
love is not mentioned once.. the truth is when the apostles preached the gospel, they did not preach about love. They did not have to because their actions showed God's love, the fact that they were all of one mind, one heart, in one accord:
Spoken to all Christians within the church in the city of Phillipi:
Phillipians 2:2 "Then make me truly happy by agreeing wholeheartedly with each other, loving one another, and working together with one mind and purpose."
How can we show the world we are followers of Jesus if we don't have oneness and unity. Love is shown by oneness and unity and a stumbling block for the gospel is the fact that God's children are divided, the world sees and knows this and sees no love between the denominations. You can preach and talk about love but show it in your actions by your unity and oneness.
Many beleivers and non-believers will read these posts we have made. I dare say that many statements are so negative about churches I can see why some would never want to darken to door of some churches. I fail to see a "you are welcome here sign" in any of your posts. There is a bias against any denomination, as they must all be bad to the bone. There are several places that give the impression the Bible says things that it does not say what is posted.
All denominations are not bad.. but scripture reveals that all denominations are not in God's will and it is not how God started His church. Joining a denomination does not equal joining the Body of Christ. Scripture reveals denominations are not God's will.. the church existed for many years without them, and they did not lack in any spiritual thing. Your own words spoke the truth in your first sentence "Denominations per se are not the Body of Christ"...
Brother here is the difference. The Body of Christ only has believers, saved people in it. Denominations have many unsaved people in it. The reason is to join a denomination you do not have to be a believer in Christ, you do not have to be saved. For hundreds of years the only requirement to join the Catholic Church or Church of England or Lutheran Church was to be born into it..and you get water baptised sprinkled as baby or adult to symbolise this. If you are born into a denomination then they say you are saved and going to heaven. Of course this produces many false converts. This is the difference between Body of Christ and denomination.. God's church and man's church. In man's church you do not have to be saved to join the church. Please be careful that non-believers reading your post do not get the idea that they can join a denomination and so be saved...do not confuse Body of Christ with denomination...believer and non-believer must know the difference.
Here is my suggestions: take a course on the Protestand reformation or read a book on it. Go and visit a conserative Bible believing Church that is a church that is in a denomination. Then look in a CONCORDANCE and study the words Jesus spoke oabou loving each other. This could let you have first hand knowledge and can speak with authority.
Oneness and unity between all believers within a city/village is in the Bible, denominations are not. Please check the Scriptures and see for yourself.