• Hi Guest!

    Please share Talk Jesus community on every platform you have to give conservatives an outlet and safe community to be apart of.

    Support This Community

    Thank You

  • Welcome to Talk Jesus

    A true bible based, Jesus centered online community. Join over 11,000 members today

    Register Log In

Did any of Abraham’s brothers sin?

Haran and Nahor were brothers of the great patriarch, Abraham.

Why did Almighty God choose Abram (Abraham) for the covenant rather than either of abram’s brothers?
Okay -- what Is the relevance -- didn't mean to be 'narky'. God chose Abram -- that doesn't mean there was anything wrong with the other two.
Sue, in the scriptures we read many occasions where the first born son sinned. The Father’s first born son is always (initially, at least), also the:
  • ‘Firstborn’... —-> ‘Most Beloved of the Father
  • ‘First Born’... —-> ‘First child born, flesh for flesh, chronologically, of a parent (Father)
Please take note of the difference... why oh why did the translators use the SAME words for two different so closely related definitions!!!!??? .... I know why!!!!

Sue, we have Cain, first born of Adam, ALSO firstborn, because, like Eve said, ‘God has given us a man from our own self’ (paraphrased!!). And also, scriptures says, ‘he that opens the womb is the most beloved...’ Like 2:23...(just to back up the definition!)

But Cain sinned and was discharged as ‘Most Beloved’... he remain ‘First Born’... cannot change that - but his status as ‘Most beloved’ is taken away...
  • Psalm 109:8
  • Acts 1:20
  • Genesis 4:25
  • Daniel 2:21
Anf guess what? ‘Another is brought up to replace him’... another son of the Father becomes the ‘Firstborn’ (most beloved). Keep reminding yourself of the difference between the two terms and apply them APPROPRIATELY... if you don’t or can’t then confusion will arise.

So where else is this seen... and hence my question:
  • Cain -> Seth ... was born to replace Abel who became firstborn but was killed by Cain (Cain first sinned by not offering the best of his produce tkGod. Then sinned further by killing Abel)
  • ..??.. -> Abr[ah]am
  • Ishmael -> Isaac (Abraham initially LOVED Ishmael!!! until Ishmael started bullying Isaac)
  • Esau -> Jacob (Esau gave up his birthright to Jacob... not good!!)
  • Rueben -> Joseph
  • Eliab -> David
  • .... -> Solomon
(If I’ve got some names wrong then sorry. I’m writing purely from memory on these issue (pun intended) and not error-checking!)

All of these great patriarchs we know that their eldest sibling sinned. So I was asking if it was the same with Abraham.

Was Abraham the eldest son, who was the eldest brother (Abram; Haran; Nahor)?
For one thing -- God promised Sarah and Abraham that He would give them a child in their old age. Sarah laughed within herself because both she and Abraham were Way past child-bearing years. Sarah proceeded to follow cultural practices and gave her handmaid to Abraham to have a child with. Ishmael was born first and then Isaac was their Natural child.

The fact is is that Everyone is a sinner.

As soon as you said "I know why" -- my inner warning flashers started 'going'.

So -- Why did the translators use the two closely related words? More than likely because they felt the context warranted it. I'm not going to debate the subject.

Cain did kill Abel and then later on Seth was born. But 'another son of the Father'? Capitalizing Father makes Him God the Father. The Father did not give birth to anyone. Adam the their father. Eve is simply commenting that God had blessed her with another son. She was Not acknowledging that God the Father was the father of her children. Notice the difference between "F" and "f".

At some time or another Every first-born child Does Die. It's part of life.

Seems that just Maybe - you're trying to make a 'deal' where there is no 'deal'.
But -- trying to answer your question -- back in Genesis 11 ; 27 Terah begot Abram, Nahor, and Haran. Haran died before his father. Then Abram and Nahor took wives and from there , there's really no record of Nahor.

Scripture doesn't tell us the birth order and apparently it doesn't matter or we'd be told.

I Have just noticed that there is both a city of Haran and one of Terah's sons being Haran. In verse 31 we find Haran both a town and a person. Which can be confusing.
Hi Sue, I did not make a preferential distinction between ‘F’and ‘f’.... I just meant, ‘the father who spawned the child’... Capitalisations are for our own preferential understanding ... it is not a scriptural difference. I’m not understanding how you thought I meant that ‘God birthed him’... the context warranted flesh from flesh birth... there are only two Spirit-Flesh CREATIONS:
  1. Adam, and
  2. Jesus
And certainly they are neither described as ‘Fathered by God’. We use the terms:
  • Created (Spirit given)
    • Sentient: Angels, Man, Animals
but obviously ‘Dust’, rocks, water, air, fire, etc... are non-sentient creations
  • Pro-Creation (Flesh from Flesh)
    • Man, animals
Angels are created being with sentient abilities... Animals have very limited sentiency. Man has “a little less than the angels - for a while!”

Both man and animals Procreate of their own...
  • SPIRIT does not procreate
  • Angels, are Spirits, and do not procreate ...
  • God, the Father, is Spirit and does not Procreate...
That’s just to let you know that I know what I’m saying... it’s unfortunate that my understanding wasn’t made clear(er) in the post. If you want to know about the Nephilims... understand that the demon angels did not ‘procreate’. They CREATED a body for themselves and PUT their OWN spirit (themselves) into those bodies to enliven them... that’s why when they were ‘destroyed’, it was the ‘body’ that was destroyed... their spirit... went to ‘jail’! And notice that the creation of Adam involved an inert, un-enlivened BODY creation INTO WHICH God blew the breath of life - and then:
  • ‘The man BECAME a living soul’
So, now you should understand who God was speaking to when he said, ‘Let us make man in our image’.

Notice that it was ‘GOD’ who made man in his own image... not the ‘us’ image... The ANGELS made the body (which is just flesh, a closure, an enclosure, a device, a mechanism) for the sentient Spirit to make use of. The spirit acts to maintain the body and use it to perform all things it deems possible in line with the physical laws of the created world. The spirit desires at all normal times to protect the body it is enclosed in from harm (not always successfully!!) but also restrains it from possibilities that are within scope of its ability. That is why Jesus often got exasperated at why some people could not do things ... he got around it by offering them ‘Faith’ that the thing could be achieved...(with help from the Holy Spirit of God).

But enough of background stuff!

Yes, I didn’t see anything about the order of birth of Abraham and his sibling nor if any sinned....

and sue, that is why I asked the question.

Are you to say to me that I shouldn’t ask a question because you don’t have an answer... or you don’t think it’s relevant?

No... not everyone knows has an answer - but then, SOMEONE might. There are those who study deeper and more diligently than others on SPECIFIC matters ... if they are on this forum then fantastic, let them answer - but don’t say it is irrelevant because YOU don’t know or care!!

I was (am) compiling a list... I see a pattern. I want to extend the list if it’s possible.

Are you trying at shaming me for ‘Searching the Scriptures’? Putting me down for ‘Just Asking’?
I was showing you from Scripture what it says. Scripture didn't have an answer for your question.

You wondered if any of them sinned -- of Course they sinned. Everyone ever born has sinned.

In Scripture "F" is referring to God the Father.

There Are people who believe that God 'fathered' children. That is why I made sure that You understood what I was talking about.

What do you mean by Jesus being a 'Spirit-flesh' creation'?

Mankind do Not become angels. People do Not become angels when they die. If that's what you're suggesting.

Why bring up the Nephilims And Where did you get Your information.

Look at Genesis 1:26 "Then God said, "let Us make man in Our image, according to Our likeness , et.

Never trying to shame anyone -- just pointing out Scripture.
Haran and Nahor were brothers of the great patriarch, Abraham.

Why did Almighty God choose Abram (Abraham) for the covenant rather than either of abram’s brothers?
For I know him, that he will command his children and his household after him, and they shall keep the way of the LORD, to do justice and judgment; that the LORD may bring upon Abraham that which he hath spoken of him -Gen 18:19

God often takes the underqualified and equips them for His glory. Abraham seem to have a quality God saw in Him that was important to His purpose.

He knew Abraham would not only follow His ways but teach his household in the way. This is integral in building a nation, hence why God chose him.

Similar threads